Why did Achilles and Odysseus fight?

Why did Achilles and Odysseus fight?

What are Achilles responses to Odysseus? Achilles responds to Odysseus’s attempt to persuade him (although we should bear in mind that Odysseus has been compelled to relay the messages of Agamemnon, and therefore his attempt to persuade Achilles is both a mix of Odysseus’s tact and Agamemnon’s offerings).

Why did Odysseus fight in the Trojan War?

Odysseus fought in the Trojan war because he had in the past sought the hand of Helen and had sworn an oath to protect her.

What does Odysseus say to Achilles How does Achilles respond?

In book 11, Odysseus and his men sail to Oceanus, where they proceed to make sacrifices in order to meet the shades of death. Odysseus initially attempts to comfort Achilles by commenting on his revered legacy, but Achilles responds by saying that he would rather be a slave than remain among the dead.

Who convinced Achilles to fight?

Fearing of defeat to the Trojans, Agamemnon summons Ajax , Odysseus, and Phoenix to persuade Achilles into rejoining the battle by means of offering gifts and the return of Briseis. Phoenix is first mentioned in book nine line two hundred of the Iliad.

Why does Achilles not accept Agamemnon’s apology?

He tells Achilles that he can achieve personal honor and glory by saving the Achaians. Achilles response is swift and at first does not seem well thought-out. They believe that Achilles’ reasons for refusing the offer are psychologically and morally valid because he does not need the gifts that Agamemnon offers to him.

Why did the gods hate Odysseus?

The god Poseidon certainly hates Odysseus, and this is because Odysseus blinded Poseidon’s son, the Cyclops Polyphemus. Odysseus then told the Cyclops his real name, out of pride, so that the monster can tell others who managed to outsmart him. Polyphemus then prayed to his father, Poseidon, to punish Odysseus.

Why did the gods punish Odysseus?

After the destruction of Troy, he and his men left for home without paying proper respect to Poseidon. For this, Poseidon punished Odysseus with what turned out to be a ten year journey home to Ithaca. Further insults against Poseidon complicated this journey. For this, Poseidon vowed Odysseus would never see his home.

Does Odysseus see Achilles in the underworld?

After Agamemnon, Odysseus encounters the greatest war hero of all, Achilles. At first, Odysseus is startled to see such a famous figure, but then he tells his story of struggle. Odysseus expresses his admiration to Achilles, telling him that he is the most honored hero of all and died with the ultimate kleos.

Is Achilles a hero?

Who was Achilles? In Greek mythology, Achilles was the strongest warrior and hero in the Greek army during the Trojan War. He was the son of Peleus, king of the Myrmidons, and Thetis, a sea nymph. The story of Achilles appears in Homer’s Iliad and elsewhere.

What did Achilles say to Odysseus in the Odyssey?

Your handout is one from the sheaf of handouts I distributed that afternoon. Imagine a rather odd, small auditorium, with strange thick walls and a thick door like on a walk-in freezer. I presume this is to permit classified briefings to be given in the room.

Who is the champion of intelligence in the Iliad?

Odysseus as the champion of heroic intelligence has already succeeded where Achilles as the champion of heroic strength had failed. Odysseus has already lived through the Iliad, as it were, and so he must know that he can take credit for the conquest of Troy.

What did Odysseus do to win the Iliad?

As for Odysseus, although he used his heroic intelligence in inventing the Wooden Horse, which was the key to the capture of Troy by the Achaeans, this success did not win for him the title of the ‘best of the Achaeans’ in the Iliad.

Why did Odysseus feel sadness when he heard the Oracle?

Since the Oracle is prophesying the conquest of Troy, and since we know that Odysseus gets the credit for this achievement, why would this hero feel sadness, not delight, when he hears an epic story that tells how the god Apollo had prophesied the conquest?